Yepp I have been playing with my friedns for quite some time, and by playing with friends I mean we sit in discord together listening to each their own music and rarely speaking mostly complaining about bdo while grinding solo in marni instances, peak gaming moment.

We could run the """dungeon""" but what's the point, it is just a waste of time 

Oh, please, don't give them any further ideas!!!!

btw, I'm not a robot

You must be a genius ! No one certainly got this idea and tried to abuse the trust of their clients before ! 

oh wait, there are gaming companies who tried that like EA, ubisoft, blizzard and they all have one thing in common today they stagnate on the market because no one trust them to not attempt to scam you or produce something worth to buy.

when people say capitalism is dying because it's an outdated system they're wrong, it's scammers trying to pass as business men who destroy capitalism.

Not complaining too much but from the first post the owner is right. Found like with a decent gear lets say 285ap390dp you can do with resources ls agris like 1b per h overall to say, without them like 500m mostly TL but when going to higher spots 300-320AP you can make same 1b silver per hour makes nonsense...

These are especially for those who are stuck with gear progression and looks into forum for more answers, yea hard part will begin now after the graduation and after getting boss gear upgraded using reform stones into fallengod ( except boots as is now the end gear items...). Well after being stuck with TET bs weapons from market ( ~30b to spent for all 3 weapons ) then go for PEN neckalce ~55B, TET-PEN 2x Earring ~25-140b, PEN belt 32-35b, also can go for PEN weapons too, MAIN - 124b , Sub- 132b,  Awk 138b.

Now when you think having a good hour getting like 500-1b per hour now do the math and see how much can you resist to grind to infinite progressing in this game.

Its a pve game with so much content but I was expecting getting some items from Bosses like weapons armos and not the same trashes all time. Can't remeber how many many times I did Vell and Garmoth to get absolute nothing worth, so many months and for others so many years to get nothing.

IMO they are loosing much more players of all type because of this ideea of very very slow progression that takes months of grind and resources just to have a very small progression or few minutes of unlucky RNG when enhancing.

If something is wrong in this game the guilty is RNG all the time and not the number behind it that in some cases are very low or very very low.

Dungeons here are so bad scripted..rewards are not so good, field bosses spawn randomly and rare but no one do them, world bosses remain an option for some rewards but more chances for their upgrade version except vell garmoth. PVP I honestly don't care as need to use a different setup that cost alot and its not worth at all.

I'm impressed as never see a game before that requires thousands or tens of thousands of hours to invest to get nearly end game gear or not even so, absurd or dedicated for those without a life? I'm close to end here, requires even more and more time to invest and at some point you'll not enjoying the game anymore.

In my opinion it was the Shai preperation event bringing in lifeskillers from abroad. Then E3 2019 also pushed BDO hard, to include Shai release. As you can see it fizzled out. 

one of the points you mentioned is what ive been saying for a while. Ever since they released the seasonal servers, it has "forced" people to skip a big chunck of the game, i posted this once on reddit and they all pissed on me by saying, "who cares about the early game its boring", "they gave us a tet bs cus its the next upgrade after seasonal and tuvala isnt good enough to grind end game spots". Like dude, tuvala gear without seasonal existing would take you at the very least a year or 2 to get. People are skipping all the green, yellow and blue armor and i know a lot will disagree with me but THATS what makes your bdo experience fun, discovering the areas and learning how everything works, now you do what they tell you and in a week you are ready to grind at miru. Getting full boss pen gear doesnt feel like an accomplishment as it used long time ago, you get free pieces here and there and by the time you are done youll have enough money for the final piece of armor.

You could say i sound jealous of people progressing faster than me who started in 2017 but tbh im not, i enjoyed the early game so so so much and i could even say it was one of the most fun experiences in gaming i ever had. So in the end, this will just force people to follow a single route for gear instead of starting from nothing and growing organically, which will give a massive rewarding feeling unlike now.

The data doesn't support your original claim period.  The actual fact is the data you showed shows the game is still perfectly healthy. 
And pretty clear you fudged your data, so a liar there too. You've been caught red handed changing data.