What were their family names?  I will check to see when they left the guild

How about the date, time and location in game of this supposed interaction with our guild member? That should be easy for you to remember since it bothered you so very much. Also, next time just dec us if you are so scary, though that's hard to believe of someone who is too timid to post on their real account.

Yeah, well no one left my guild in that time frame, lol.

That should be easy enough to prove, and end this lil d$%k waving contest shouldnt it?

Go ahead, post the proof with the time frame from when the last memeber left, till now. Or enough out of you, cause im sure no one cares.

That's an obvious name and shame. Do it in private messages, not on the forums. 

You link one thread that isnt your, and yet you still are here wasting your time and everyone time instead of keeping the only thread you were able to link, alive, as its inactive since around 5 months.

At best you only display some sort of pretty toxic behavior coming fight others people idea you doesn't like. When, so far i very quickly saw, no "pve gang" came to be annoying in your pvpve karma thing thread like your "pvpve gang" is doing here.

In short you just go all out assuming whatever non sense, when i only say you are just wasting all your time in pve server request thread fighting others instead of being interesting and attract others with ideas in appropriate thread. ( = threadS related to pvpve )

As thoses supposed proposal just sank forgotten and ignored in such pve server thread where you are no added value as your "wish" do not match the initial thread topic.

And no, i never saw any of your supposed proposal, otherwise i would say it, i dont know what kind of paranoia you are living into.

Make it simple : If i say something, its because its what i think. I have no time to lose and waste with such infantile behavior like the one you are speaking about.

So, my obvious and constructive participation is not good enough for you because I'm not the opener and I didn't feel the need to spam this topic?

Lul again. 

One suggestion is good enough when it is well made, we don't need to keep spamming it. On the other hand, there are topics that keeps repeating the same nonsense about pure pve, without being constructed, and relying on a kind of pure obsession, or even fanatism about pve.

So sorry for you, but if we feel like beating some sense in these topics, we can and we do.

What are you still doing here being toxic and fight others ideas ?

Because you created one constructive answer months ago ( so you say, didnt read all that as i doesnt interest me, and yet, unlike you, you dont see me go fight and be a toxic toward such topic) it will excuse your, and others toxic pk-lover behavior.

Stop spam your "disagrement" since ALL that time and in a very obsessive way in such topic to only focus on being more "obsessive" toward your supposed constructive behavior, and maybe you will not appear as the toxic you really look to be.

You seem fragile if you need to play such infantile self glorification here 

But then why you are wasting your time here , been also toxic (most of the time) since DEVs every year, including last Ball, stated that they gona keep the servers PvPvE?

And like stated many times to you. This is topic with idea. Everyone is free to back it up or to be against it. Yes we have the right to post against it, no matter how much you hate it. Its forum, its not your personal blog.