When the blackstars was added they kinda had some point, but today it's just an entry gate for new players without adding any value to the game. Players who actually play the game already have shittons of those anyway, there is no reason for them to exits.

Delete those clutter items.

???

You want to remove one item which allows us to get access to the BS awak and BS offhands questlines (in addition to the BS armors quests) and is a requirement to finish those questlines, and another item which allows us to create some cups and various enhancement stones?

I'm not sure to follow your reasoning here? Oo

I assumed players who read it have atleast like 60iq to see that I meant to remove those items from recipes/quests aswell since that's what would make sense, but overestimating the avarage player's intelligence was clearly my fault.

Your post kinda lost people.  Blackstar weapons are still among the top end in the game and it's rather hard to enhance them without Mass of Pure Magic.  Now that Godr-Ayed have been added, masses are required to make the enhancement stones for those as well.  While I do have a fair quantity in storage, doing away with them would be a bit of problem at some point.  It's highly unlikely PA would be willing to modify the game to remove all the Spector dependencies and they are a rare drop to boot, so while a bunch of us must be low IQ, your suggestion doesn't make a lot of sense.

Talking about IQ but making a topic with a relatively stupid title, lol

New player have access to tuvala, they can make PEN boss gear.

New player should not have directly access to Blackstar, in what game new player have directly access to the best?

They can't even handle it. Failstack, ressources, money the amount needed is not something a newbie can handle.

Just make them sellable on the MP now 

Easy 

???

My bad, let me rephrase it.

Could you please tell us the expected benefit of removing the existence of these items from the game? 

This topic makes no sense.

Remove the only resource for BS weapons? Without giving any alternative? WTAF?!

Am I missing anything here?

OP better to have thought about the consequences...

He is partially right.

What's the difference if the formula for creating e.g. Flawless Magical Black Stone requires: Sharp Black Crystal Shard, Hard Black Crystal Shard and Mass of Pure Magic or only Sharp Black Crystal Shard and Hard Black Crystal Shard.