Do you really want to compare online shooters to mmorpg? Muuuhahhahahaaa.

Ok, then in which of them do you lose something after death? oh yes in none.

I wrote again: remove the loss of exp, crystals, trade items after death, then there can be pvp, I will not care then.

And as long as toxic players cause intentional mob-induced death, open pvp has no place in BDO. And I'll be karmabombing players like that every time.

I'm not commenting on pve versus pvp servers.

I would like to comment on your statement regarding Pearl Abyss (PA) will not change their "stance."  I would direct your attention to their own game description found here mentions nothing about forced PVP - https://www.pearlabyss.com/en-US/Company/About/Games#null

Poor Timmy... doesnt know that you dont lose xp and crystal on PvP death. Mobfeeded. Ok, why remove PvP when the problem is PvE death. Why not make topic about no xp and crystals loss on death from mobs?? Why? Is it just basesless hate against  PvP. Looks like.

There could be so many ideas but all goes for remove PvP. Let me remind you that 99,99% of PvPers dont care about lifeskillers. Ofc there are some griefers, but how many PKs are made from othere lifeskillers just becasue want all the spot for themselves.

 The idea of second gear is good. Here is another one - when you have lifeskiller gear, if you get PKed you get max negative karma and insta go to jail. But that gear should be always visible to prevent abuse.

There will be always some griefers, they will be there even if only PvE server exist. People must understand this and ask themselves is this realy the problem or they exagarated it too much. Come on cant be that hard if you die once in few weeks.

You went to pearl abyss's website to get your point ookay. Have you actually watched anything with them making comments on PvE Servers, Like at all. They have said for over 5 years they will not add servers to be pure pve , well also stating they would mitigated methods to stop players camping lifeskillers an nodes. If you didnt notice marni realm now exists and seasons. They even stated they will not go any further than this. Other things like teleporting they said they may change their point of view if the map gets to big which i assume with the upccoming expansion that is why abyss was added. Yes things change but i think the PvE server will never happen because they will have very big backlash from the community.

Gta v online is a MMORPG...  

The part where getting negative karma will make a lot of players angry and make it worse for Life Skillers. But from the other hand: putting them in jail should be okay. Also 'gears should always be visible to prevent abuse'. The problem is.... Pearl costume hides them. I suggest there should be a badge next to the player's name to signal other players that: "I have Life Skill Gears Equipped. Please don't attack me!"

Will that be okay?

Edit, I am going to update my brainstorm-graph...

We already have a jail... Pila ku jail...

If your so scared go to the desert someone kills you get a friend to kill them send them to jail for 30 mins or longer

It should not be PAs problem that Carebears get their panties in a twist over being killed when they trash talk , intentionally grief or used any method possible to annoy another player minding their own buisness. PvP players can be toxic to sure, but this is rare and the same goes for PvE players being toxic. Your making this sound like you want to change a game with a already consistent player base an change it to something it was never intended to be. You an Senemedar want to change a game thats already was built on foundation of being based around PvX remove that foundation an then you get season servers after 3 weeks of seasons starting 

Titan, stop telling players to make seasonal characters and tell the player base to bugger off. Many don't want that. Also, IWalkAlone is trying to give ideas... which is a good start. Also, we don't want to remove PVX. Instead of trying to find ways, you want to drive out the Life Skillers!

Sigh... let's try and find out how we can help PA implement something better! Okay? From this point, no knives and pitchfork.

You are the one assuming i want lifeskillers to leave. Considering i do lifeskills my self thats a bit insulting. I never said to make just season characters i just told you how PA stopped new players being farmed same with lifeskillers they also added marni realm for a hour a day so you are guaranteed one hour per day no one interrupts you. Litterally a hour a day PvE server

Which i do wonder when they will add butchering/hunting an other places that have mobs to harvest to the Marnis realm since they gave a hint they would but i havent seen any notes on it or proper commentary on it

Alright then, come up with a PvX idea instead of a PvE idea, I challenge you...

Something that integrates both PvP and PvE, bringing the communities together instead of pushing them apart.

As others have already made clear, further division is futile and goes against the game design as well as the concept of an mmorpg. BDO is already suffering from a loss of multiplayer gameplay, as other posts (such as BDO is soulless etc) have shown.

So, come up with something truly PvX