Because the post is too long to submit here in the BDO forums, I've put the entire thing on reddit. Here is the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/blackdesertonline/comments/11eec2d/solare_season_2_feedback_in_hopes_for_a_better/

They ignored feedback from preseason to s1

They ignored feedback from s1 to s2

What are you even hoping for?

Like the things that you mention here was not fixed since preseason despite it was already asked by hundreds of times by hundreds of players on various channels, yet PA did not care to fix even a single meaningfull issue in AOS. It's clear as day that they don't care at this point, so just reroll to some FOTM and abuse it for the free stuff, just like everyone else. It will never be a proper competitive PvP mode...

I was fairly ok with the entire post, until the remove resistance part.
Hey, if you explain me how you are gonna remove resistance from the game, all the changes needed etc... I'm all with you... But you simply say "remove resistance, it sucks" then no thanks, because you cant remove resistance without doing a LOT and i mean A LOT of in depth changes... Look at how many stuff has "Ignore resistance" or "Resistance +%", passives, crystals, weapons etc... You just can't remove resistance without doing any changes and say its fine.
Again, if you explain me what is your idea of changes to remove resistance, then i will listen. But saying "remove resistance, it sucks" without any idea on how to execute it... no thanks.

Also what about large scale?

We need translated Korean version and shared in Korean forum and upvote it to 100, I am confident enough to say once we done that we will get what we need

Good Post, OP 

Good post and hugely agree with most of the AoS-specific system issues that are sorely needed:

Waiting time BSR gain is not okay.

Disconnect wait time interactions with cooldowns recovering during waiting period is not okay.

BSR 200% are too strong for some classes.

V sniffing should be removed (such as protected recovery as mentioned).

Map cheese/gimmicks/stalling and stuck in map terrain need to be fixed/removed.

Add a report function.

Weapons being put away on CC needs to be fixed.

Drastically more silver/caphras/stacks/etc. rewards for PvP / AoS are needed.

Remove time slot limitations.

Evaluate down smashes to be standardized on a limited number of non-primary skills for all classes, or remove completely.

Comments on a few of the topics:

BSR earring / offin / eva accessories : don't remove these options, just continue to rebalance brackets to allow more evasion/accuracy/DR/AP/utility trade-offs.  I thought the most recent AoS had the most diversity out of any gear in any mode in BDO ever.  Things like BSR earrings and AP evasion accessories are a huge step in the right direction.   The gearing was implemented well this season.

Removing resistances: Rather than remove, just replace resistances with a different kind of defensive stat (like additional damage reduction during CC/FG only).  The game does need some kind of defensive options for less-protected classes since 1 CC = death usually,  but RNG CC is not the solution.  Removing more RNG with the new glove crystals was a huge step in the right direction, but the long term fix is to repurpose the resistance stat completely (and possibly add other kinds of meaningful defensive options that directly trades off with offensive stats)

it's actually easy, you only make them work in pve.

Top 10 solutions of the year

Please, we need these changes PA!

And here we are to witness another great suggestions of list for AoS die without even making to adventurer feedback board. Meanwhile meaningless suggestions like, Shai leggings cencorship, outfit wardrobe, etc etc. Makes it to the adventurer feedback board.