It's a qol feedback. Just like how they recently updated the horse "stumbling" when going down a slope. One can argue its not "needed", but its also "needed" at the same time for a much smoother gameplay. Its not gamebreaking, just like a t10 dine infinite run on water is not gamebreaking. No one here who disagree have ever give a reason how this is bad thing / explain step by step how this can be use "griefing" tool vs current t10 dine. But a lot of people here (who probably owns a dine and tested it) agrees that this is "needed". (260+ upvote vs 9 downvote)

I was fine without infinite pot being on family inventory, yet they updated it for qol. Heck I was even fine without magnus, but they've added it, which is gamechanging at the time. How is t10 dine running infinitely gamebreaking / abuse / whatsoever u think its bad?

Apples and oranges . . .

Agree. but whether or not its an apple or oranges. its still a qol. And thats what we want to get.

Infinite stamina is excessive and here we have compromise. 

I've had my T10 Dine for a few days now, the throwing off in the water can be replaced with your suggestion, great. Slow down to a trot, the annoying slow kind you get when your land horse runs out of stamina. 

Also, the water stamina should regenerate if your horse is idle and you are dismounted, on land. The fact that it doesn't is odd.

lmao no. The purpose of this suggestion is to remove annoyance. Even tho it is somewhat sounds better, this is just replacing one annoyance with different type of annoyance. My suggestion is more like no other skills can be use and run like normal horse (t6-t8) without sprint skill. Maybe add a debuff icon showing that it is on this "slower" state, and you will passively regain water stamina when the debuff is active.

I really don't feel T10 Dine is as weak as people are saying. I also don't think in this trot state it should regain stamina, but whatever. Not going to argue with you either. PA sees this thread and they see organized mobs are upset. I'm sure they will buff T10 Dine somehow, and hopefuly T10 Doom because that horse is severely underperforming compared to Peg/Dine. At the very least, T10 Doom should run so fast it gets air slightly above ground and not even rocks or twigs slow it down.

fine.  give it unlimited water running.   give T10 peggy teleport to any unlocked node skill.   

I agree with the original posting about having the water bar be unlimited, but I do not htink the horse should be usable in the Margoria Ocean to preserve Carracks. I would also recommend increasing the unicorn buff that gives stats and heal over time. The current buff is identical to the tier 9 Unicorn and this would also gave another "flare" factor to the tier 10 version of it while also giving it a greater purpose in Nodewars and Siege content. 

Very good Suggestion.  I was really hoping to at least be able to make it from Velia to Iliya Island in 1 shot , thats not a hugh distance and still need to stop at least once to recharge the water stamina.  
And that wouldn't need to be a thing if they would fix Velia Wharf :/   They need to make the Safe Zone area there Larger so ships can get in and out. 

I even had to make myself a map of locations that are reachable as so many islands you can only sprint to reach otherwise the drain is way to fast and you get thrown off. I also never understood the block on magoria/ross sea as there would be no way one could reach LoMl with this but at least crows nest would be a option. Either make it recharge just standing on water or at least increase the stamina by another 50% then at least any island is at least reachable with using movement skills.