Have a rotation every other months with SA or keep Solarce perma while bringing in shadow arena.

Remove kama buff needed for loot box. Adjust Silver and add blackstar and god tier items to loot. 

Also for characters make it eithor Succ or Awaken. So long as its not plagued by hackers you got fun game mode to bring around few times a year people would play it a bit.

When it was live on BDO was prob most fun i ever had. I was making decent silver(for its time) while geting all the enhancement mats. Id pvp for progress in heart beat. 100-200m hour doing pvp would be so good for many players. Need fun stuff when tired of boring brainless grind. 

No point lying anymore, we all know, noone care about shadow arena/ Solaric PVP, you just want free silver for doing nothing.

Pretty much this. 95%+ of the players in SA was players who "grinded" that instead as it gave more money than regular grind...

That is what the disconnected devs missunderstood as "sucess" and thought it will be sucessfull as standalone lmao

Main issue with stand alone, they can't really monetize mini game that have nothing to do with main game and w/o rewards or with normal rewards like RBF its would be pretty much ~60 players peak.

And second bigest problem with both Shadow Arena and Circus of Solare is that PVP is the reward, its doesn't need to be  rewarded, those "casual" players who want to have "fun" in PVP, should stay away from it, because even at "equal gear" their "skill" is only good to enrage other players.

PA very much can do token based rewards like for Pit/Dungeon and its will be perfectly fine, because rewards are decent, but its will be "dead content" because grinding centaurs give more silver, but those casual players still won't go grind anywhere at all.

whats the problem with being rewarded for something that is fun? This makes it even more fun or not?

Because those "mini games" have nothing to do with original game, if you want to play those "fun" game, go and play them, but we all saw Shadow Arena online- 12 players, noone want to have "fun" they just want free rewards

Because fun without rewards it's not fun anymore.

All dead conten in BDO is dead becuase:

1. Don't give rewards (eg. Yar, why we don't have daily quest: win one Yar for 10 crones)

2. Require a party

3. Are too hard.

Eg. Atoraxxion. I really want to play it, I want to gather all the knowledge. But: entry item, party, no rewards and epic hard. Just give us solo 200 AP version and will be fantastic.

If i remember correctly you are that person who said "posting GS" in boss discord in order to find a grp not acceptable. Ofc you can't get into dungeon, no one want to carry  gearless/clueless backup with them. And yet, sometimes there is partyes who accept any 5th person, because they can do easy do it with 4, they just need 5th to enter boss room.

200 GS? What is that ? PRI tuvala ? For season you need like DUO tuvala to  complete it w/o knowing any mechanics.

Also what you mean by not fun with out rewards ? There is rewards, good rewards, its just you who think they bad and want more.

Having trouble understanding a simple sentence?

Solo and fun. Not party and s. 200 AP not 200 GS. Content for everyone, not again another s. 300 AP for noone.

Yes i'm honestly having trouble to understand why people playing progress based MMORPG and ask for solo no gear content, just play single player game rather than asking to change game for yourself.