In saying in comparison to stuff I have fought in FFXIV these bosses are cake in comparison just looking at mechanics as a whole.( I'm not taking into account how much chip damage things do to players  or any of that.)

In terms of death or how bad dying is effecting the party you mess up a mechanic in FFXIV you also die and normally it also results in a party wipe. This is nothing new. Ya there are battle resses but for savage content unless you out gear the fight you won't make dps checks later. Battle resses are more to learn a fight.

You can't add content like the last boss in Vahmalkea to a game like BDO. Why? Because the facts are that a large percentage of BDO players are idiots. Latest example: last world bosses event. Only the stronger versions of bosses had an increased chance of dropping hearts. The first bosses in Europe after maintenance are Kutum and Offin. Offin is the first because he gives 3 drops, then Kutum because he's worthless anyway. And what happened? While we fought Offin, idiots killed common Kutum. BDO players can't even understand  simple rules of the event, so the fight with the last Vahmalkea boss is completely beyond them. Add to this forced party, high difficulty and most players with poor items and you have the answer why Atoraxxion turned out to be a total failure.

This sounds suspiciously like wow like mmos. The reason why no one does dungeons because they don't really have a place in this game. We are playing a KR style open world mmo.

That's not why people are not doing them....

You can have a open world mmo game and still have instanced dungeons and content. As long as the open world is still most of the game time which it is it still  it won't effect anything.

Archeage had dungeons that were instanced  it's also the closest to what bdo is they are very similar games in what they provided to the players. A sandbox.

Sorry there's more to MMOs then solo grinding mobs in a circle.

No it's not a failure. People that run them consistently  and efficently make good money. No BDO players knowledge is not the issue as many  BDO players play other games as well.  Gasp!

The problem lies  with the reward ammount vs grinding is only slightly more then grinding so people don't want to take the time to learn the fights even though the experience and gameplay is much more interesting then killing things in a circle. Also the current dungeon content is 280 ap 350 DP which for the people past that they can make way more money else where with no need to learn a fight 

But saying there's no interest in dungeons is false there's people asking about  it in game there are people looking to try them it's just the means to try them currently requires more effort requires you to get a full 5 man party together normally guild mates or after constantly spamming world chat. If there was a functioning dungeon queue I garentee it would be ran more. Because your removing annoyances to run them.

the first dungeon is very simple
the second dungeon is very buggy and there are several videos sent to support regarding these bugs and they have never fixed it
If the 2nd dungeon is less done it's only their fault

In addition they put rng mechanics in this dungeon, an rng that wipes the whole team.. and a mechanic based on the graphic quality of each player, something that we can't control because where "x" will see the lights, "y" will see nothing, where "x" will see yellow, "y" will see white..
In short the 2nd dungeon is full of design concerns and bug / rng that make it a waste of time to do it

And to come back to the other comparisons with other MMOs
On other games, dungeons are used to have unique rewards, whether accessories / armor or items that are used to craft them.
The rewards of bdo dungeons are useless, the only thing they can bring is a distortion clone..

I'm sorry if it's not what you want to hear. But it's what you sign up for when you started to play bdo. It's like wow players complaining there's no circle grinding in the game what do you think the population of players would say to that. More than likely they would tell the person complaining that there are plenty of games on the market that offer grinding.

I've seen players LFG in the global chat about Atoraxxion actively from time to time. The dungeon is EZ, when you know what you're doing. Ive done it too and was successful(with my guild). Fun fact: I didn't even have 260 AP back then with non-seasonal char. It was a long time ago. We had a good coordination and perception about any situation. To me it was fun doing it with my guild and would do it again, whenever I get time.

Same as first. Tell me how to fight last boss if I don't see lava on the floor (many others players also).

Adn PA don't care because on high details problem does not exist.

For me, this whole fight is stupid. 

1. You can't respawn.

2. Stupid boss split with hp reg from 51% to 100% when split fail (and same time more and more mobs comes and attack).

3. Stupid colors symbols. It's hard to tell them apart and additionally you lose them if you move too fast. Also players interfere with each other.

4. And what I wrote at the beginning: invisible lava that has instant kill.

5. Stupid drop (almost no drop) "move forward" entry items. One player has 10 another 2 and only time is wasted. Also if you back you can't return. You need again drop next 10.

6. Stupid mini bosses mechanics and stupid random big boss spawn. Also epic s. flying mobs.

Conclusion: s. and stupid. Also no rewards / trash rewards.

I'll say it again: give us the 240 AP solo version and I'll do it every week.