You bring up some good points, and while I do not 100% understand Zeroden's full suggestions with all the ins-and-outs he's suggesting, I did come up with something.  Wondering what you think of it, lookiong for positive, constructive feedback on this proposal and potential flaws that would prevent the system from being a net positive impact for the game.  I'll present the idea and the bulletpoints associated with it, things like it's limitations to prevent abuse and workings.

Your thoughts?

I do have one, very specific, scenario I am concerned with, however, as I realize nothing in this world is ever perfect.  This system not being an exception.  Zeroden brought this up and I am trying to figure out a way to prevent this, very specific, scenario. 

Say you are grinding in a solo grind spot and multiple players, from different guilds, shows up -- they all send a Vendetta on you at the same time.  You are then forced to leave.  You can swap channels and this will effectively cancel all Vendetta's that were sent to you and each of those players who sent it will be down one out of the maximum two alotted Vendettas they have per week = this is the biggest consequence for them for using it to force you out, but is it enough?  To me, it's yes and no.  Yes, because you are given a way to end the Vendetta at your choosing and the players who sent it to you, quite literally, wasted a valuable resource.  No, because you lose the spot on that channel.  I do not forsee this happening frequently, however, no more frequently than what the more lenient GvG System allows, at least. 

The current GvG System is more lenient, but, when a player is not in a guild, they are allowed free reign to grief others.  They do assume a "safety net", however, by being guildless -- but this "safety net" can be abused.  How do we prevent this abuse?  It is 100% of the time guildless players who are allowed the maximum amount of griefing in this game, IMHO.  Guilds can at least declare war.  Guildless players cannot.  This allows them literal free reign to grief others via farming on top of other players, ruining their experience in this way, with zero repercussion, because there simply is no form of prevention of bad behavior via retribution, nor is there any penalty for doing so.  A penalty will be difficult to apply to this, so I believe retribution is the best way -- in a way that aligns with BDO's core gameplay, main content, and abiding by current rules laid out by the Operational Policy and ToS.

Sounds flawless.  A great idea with no exploits.

This way I can make up some FAKE vendetta against EVERY SINGLE weak player and just wreck them because I FEEL LIKE IT.  But that's not exploiting anything because I will do it ONE NEWB at a time ROFL.

GIT GUD and go to Arsha.

No one is suprised you DO NOT ADHERE TO YOUR OWN STANDARDS either.

"Surprise: Trying to outfarm others on the same spot is also a form of PvP."

Now lets hunt down some Shai's I have a "cough Vendetta" against them, nothing to do with their gimped PVP class.

If I find any flaws in your bad ideas I'll let you know.  Right now I can't find any.

I'd upvote this proposal in its own thread, as having it buried down in a "Let us harass anyone, from lifeskillers to 49ers, with no consequences" thread isn't ideal.

I've made several threads in the past exploring ways address the Karma System's exploitability.  I'm sure Zeroden didn't intend his proposal to encourage harrassment, especially on lifeskillers to 49ers, maybe it was an oversight, but I'm sure that specific issue could be addressed within his proposal.  I'll consider making a new thread with my proposal, thanks for your feedback.  Although, I am concerned that it will devolve, from what would be intended to be constructive and aimed at positive change for the game, to toxic drivel like this one, sadly, has.

I've made several threads in the past exploring ways address the Karma System's exploitability.  I'm sure Zeroden didn't intend his proposal to encourage harrassment, especially on lifeskillers to 49ers, maybe it was an oversight, but I'm sure that specific issue could be addressed within his proposal.  I'll consider making a new thread with my proposal, thanks for your feedback.  Although, I am concerned that it will devolve, from what would be intended to be constructive and aimed at positive change for the game, to toxic drivel like this one, sadly, has.

I know reading isn't your strong point (aside from being toxic, IDK what is, TBH.  I mean, who makes 5+ BDO unlinked forum accounts, gets banned on them all, and keeps coming back to continue being toxic anyway?), but if you read, this problem has already been considered.  In fact, was the very first potential problem I thought of addressing.

1)  There would be a limit to the amount of Vendettas players can send per week.  1 - 3, possiblly; the exact number is tentative, however the idea remains in tact = Vendettas are a limited resource that should be used wisely.  This would prevent players from your statement of "I will do it ONE NEWB at a time ROFL", that you so eloquently described.

2)  Players can only send one Vendetta at a time.  If a player has an active sent-Vendetta, they cannot issue another one until said Vendetta is ended.

3)  All active Vendettas are automatically cancelled via channel swap of any party involved in said Vendetta.

Just because YOU'D use the system in a toxic manner, it doesn't mean everyone would.  But even if you did choose to use it like an egomaniac, the system has built-in prevention measures that take your toxic actions into consideration.

I think I've thought of all possible ways to abuse it, but if anyone else -- aside from you -- can think of any other ways it can be abused, I'm all ears.  Clearly, if this is the only rebuttal you have, I'm 10 steps ahead of you.

Like everyone does. specifically because of the annoying replies from one specific person. I wonder who that might be that goes around systematically shitting up every thread on pvp topics.

Oh and I saved the BEST for last.  When I find someone I dominate via class and gear score.  I use the VENDETTA system to MOB FEED them.  That way I get unlimited attempts without ever going red.