I really don't know what's dumber:

1. Giving the boat to one person that is part of a siege winning guild (seeing how sea content and sieges are... worlds apart)?

2. Making the terror of the seas an rng drop for all the other plebs that enjoy the bug-ridden, content-lacking sea faring part of the game?

3. Making the boat even bigger than the carrack (when the carrack is already pointlessly big, completely empty and giving a much weaker sensation of speed during breezy sail than the caravel/galleass) so that the tiny ports can be an even worse collision hell than they already are?

4. Making the dreadnaught a temporary item. Assuming the stats are improved, the size brought down to accomodate for more than 1 boat in a harbor... What's the point? It doesn't progress your fleet, it doesn't give you the feeling of "pride and accomplishment"... It does nothing.

I'm assuming it's a temporary item because they have no new sea content in the pipeline. No new barters, drops, monsters, locations from which to get the materials that would be required to upgrade the carrack.

For the other dumb elements, I guess it's laziness. They really couldn't think of anything sea-content related to tie the boat to other than they favorite: rng. They've probably forgot completely how sea content is in their game (judging by the "fix" to bartering that they've also presented)...

I sound very bitter and i probably am. 
But i believe this feedback board is a joke and useless as they will only release what's in the works already. But i'm a dreamer so i'll try gain and again. I've been trying since end 2019 after they introduced the great expedition. 0 important things have been fixed, a few QoL improvements but nothing that really matters or nothing really the way we needed it. i always accomodate to the situation, but it feels so painful that the pleasure of it is gone. (it's the same for t10, i do it with brain shut off, and clic without any hopes. the sad part is when you get your so much desired item, not even a smile, just relief: "finally")
i'm very hard on GM's/CM's or whoever has power because they seem to do whatever they want totally ignoring what is said and plebiscited here. If you can't do anything, just tell us, be honest. We know you are not superhuman and we probably hurt your feelings. 
But we are the ones playing the game... we are the ones suffering from the bugs/flaws/exploits... until they become too heavy on us and we leave. Maybe it's the final goal? casual players who stay 2 months spends a few bucks and move on without any complaining.

No, it's not. Because the winner of the castle does need the gear - assuming they don't already have it (which they do, usually) - to win said castle.

They "fixed" the Training profession by making the last 2 stages of the breeding (well, awakening, as they called it) completely rng, making all the hours spent capturing and training horses completely pointless. And to add a pinch of salt to injury, a beginner 1 trainer has the same odds of taming a horse as a Guru 50 has now - all it takes is one lump of sugar.

They seem to have "fixed" sea content too, now, by giving dedicated sailors the finger and, pretty much, gifting the "best" (I'mma still call it dumbest) boat in the game to people who probably don't give a rat's ass about sailing. And, of course, making the last stage of gear acquisition for sailing, again, rng-based and, even more frustrating, temporary. 

Who's designing these "fixes"? J's dog?

Obv, they just want that "see we listen to feedback, we totally didnt plan to do this with or without your feedback at this time at all :)"

Here I was as someone who has been getting back into BDO, and actually getting into different aspects of the game rather than just doing a little bit of lifeskilling here and there on my Shai every now and again, being super happy when they first showed this boat off at the Calpheon Ball. I've been slowly working toward my first carrack, thinking of getting the carrack skin despite the expense but also being like.. "I don't know, it was stated that the new ship being temporary is subject to change. That could mean we *will* get a permanent version of it and the carrack skin would just become a really fancy paper clip. Maybe a permanent version would involve getting all four Carracks, geared out and it'd be a tradein for one." I mean, to me that made sense.. considering it's suppose to be the "king of all ships" more or less.. but looking at some of those stats, yeesh. I must say I am baffled beyond reason by the four cannons for a ship that's bigger than one with nine per side...

I can understand people's stance about there not really being a reason for a stronger ship with how ocean content currently is, but one could say the same about Tier 10 horses and that doesn't stop the demands for T10 Doom's release. It's not a necessity, but its still a moreso extravagant goal to work toward, as with all things really. However, if this ship is made more powerful than a carrack - giving them out even if they're temporary on a "permanent" basis, is kind of a big slap to the time commitment and dedication of people who have geared out Carracks and it's definitely not the route to go if the goal is to get more people interested in ocean content.

How about instead of implementing this OBVIOUSLY horrid ship system, just delete everyones carrack,  remove wharf manages, remove the ocean(replace with sand keep the no mini map ruling like the desert) make vell a land boss(now walkable coz sand)
turn crews into workers to compensate (Remove NOL  and give each person with it a gift pack full of good deed rings  and +75 hp potion)
^ obvious sarcasm but have to specify coz internet

this new ship mechanic is a MASSIVE slap in the face to the entire sailing community who for YEARS has had to deal with insanley frustrating and horrible glitches and bugs(ships breaking at whafs, desync issues during pvp),Low bartering income, tedious cc grinding, very low to pointless smh income, the same 6 quests to upgrade  to carrack(we need more variety). how often have the devs said this is coming that is coming, oh we will fix that issue oh we going to fix that bug, and what did you guys do? $60 ship skin(near 100 for us aussies)
PLEASE do not do this, please stop this in it tracks seiges guild do not need a ship for what?  what could they POSSIBLY need a ship for(they most likley would have their own anyway) also with laughable stats as Nicetoes stated.

this is the equivalent of finally giving the ocean community a cookie, but you find out its toothpaste not mint.
please do not implement this ship give it to us real sailors who need some kind of content. im honestly so over this game im desperate for something to enjoy the game again(i afk horses and play other games then node war) but hearing even a small ocean buff got me excited again, i will even gladly do 99% of the work designed the damn thing for you as many of us would.

rant over

These stats make it a great bartering ship....except it means running out of parlay even faster and waiting on the coldown of the scroll even longer. I would perhaps still make the effort to upgrade my Advance into this, but the current implementation is beyond pointless. I do agree with the reduced firepower. Logic would then demand a second dreadnought with laughable cargo space, but all rigged for combat.

The idea of ther Dreadnaught being tied to siege battles is just nuts.  How about rewarding players who actualy do ocean content.  Also the stats are sub par as compared to already existing ships. Why give a reward to someone who has NOT put any time into sailing?  I just dont get the mentality of these so called developers.   Also saw NO acknowledgement of fixing the many BUGs with ocean content.  Also I dont yap and complain about rewards for those folks who love to grind and do PVP as thats a choice they make but seeing most all loyalty rewards go to those folks with little to none being given to those folks who have spent many hours upgrading and doing ocean content is just wrong.  I am not asking for anything to be taken away from each playstyle BUT stop leaving out those who enjoy life at sea..

LA NUOVA BARCA DEVE ESSERE PERMANENTE

non mi sembra giusto dare la possibilità di usare la nuova nave soprattutto a chi può vincere castelli la maggior parte di loro fa pvp e solo pvp se ne fregano del mare o delle barche mettilo a chi apprezza davvero il mare come esempi a coloro che arrivano a una serie di fatti di baratto.
E perché non renderlo permanente a differenza di tutte le altre abilità della vita devi starci dietro per mesi per fare la fattoria della barca monete corvo per l'attrezzatura della barca fare 25.000 baratti per sbloccare i percorsi passare ore dietro per completare tutti i baratti fare gli stessi soldi che può fare un altro giocatore con quasi tutte le altre abilità della vita o solo 1 ora di grind più difficile se come dici tu è troppo grande e potente per renderlo permanente secondo me e molti altri giocatori non è così ma se tu pensa così perché non nerf un po' e renderlo permanente almeno aggiungere qualche contenuto anche al mare in modo da lavorare per prenderlo in modo da attivare i tanti marinai che sono fermi da mesi o anni.

Giving away an even better boat than a player who spends months making his own even if it only lasts 7 days is really very sad