BDO has pvp, but I don't take the people seriously who think BDO is a pvp game. SORRY.
What is the purpose of a guild? Node wars, etc, right, what is the purpose of a small guild? What is the purpose of a life skill guild? Oh, to life skill and then gear up for node wars haha.
I know there WAS crafting or something at houses, which interested me before I quit, so much that I bought a guild house, and I was like U CANT DO ANYTHING RLY. WHY?
Doesn't it make sense to have guild workshops? Player workshops would be cool, too. But things that were set up with a little extra complexity, like workers to assign, put in the mats, produce whatever... not bs guild mats or smh mats, but like normal mats (STEEL, etc,) or do whatever and be able to produce the same items you might want to do on the market/crates except do it more efficiently. Then, just like there is central market... I know PA wants to sell VP and get that 30% tax on people, but I would like to see workshops accessible, too. Guild workshops, can search by name, do biz with only your friends, collaborate. THIS IS SANDBOX MATERIAL. THIS IS WHAT KEEPS LATE GAME MMOS GOING. You'd put in a whole new class or area, but something like that would be mechanically simple and would be so much cooler!
So you got your workshop where you can buy order and sell. SEEMS LEGIT. Seems like a reason to have a guild, don't you think? Would it end up being exploited, maybe in a game breaking way when someone figures out a loophole, yes, probably, but they can just ban and fix. Repeat after me: ban and fix. Don't remove content cuz people are jerks!
Make BDO interactive!