That's interesting. Because an enemy decided to declare war for the opposite reason you claim they're for. Simply to harass us without consequence. 

Can i get the name of your guild and the offending guild? Id like to follow up on this claim.

This is nonsense no high geared player with grief on orcs waste of time for 4 kills and become red lol. Better go on Arsha and do fight endlessly. Now everyone will go on your spot and just ks u for no reason and without consequences and u will not be able to do anything. You will call me out ? Block and report tell me what u gonna do with those changes if I enter on spot which you were first ? Ask me to leave ? I say no and ignore u ? Now what ?

Implementing the PA proposed changes in NA/EU will in the long run kill the game.
PA will empower the griefers.

PA will remove the thrill of open world, with player interaction. Making for a boring game, loosing it's uniqueness and the reason most ppl in the first place got into BDO.
And why would we want to play a boring generic game. Im sure we all could find other games that's not empowering griefers and put our money in those games instead. Plenty of other games coming out soon on UE5 will look just as nice.

this is all thrown out at the same time to mask the cron stone price increase by 50% and p2w potential increase.

You can give whatever anecdotal you want and reword "contesting your spot / server" to "harrassment" to drag the conversation into your own goalpost - however in the end of the day chances are one of YOUR guildmates harassed someone else, abused the karma / protection system. Now they want to insure your guild can no longer pose a future threat going forward or at the very least can be contested off the server without waiting for a 15 minute dec timer to go through.

The alternative going forward is as following. Instead of declaring war and contesting a spot / server outright, giving both guilds an opportunity to reach out to their allies or friends or gvg guilds to come help and giving a feeling of authentic pvp in what was up until now a competitive community wide arms race - is being walked up on by someone who genuinely knows the karma system and how to abuse it in a dp set, attempt to feed you to mobs / slow spam you. And then swap to tuvala gear once the other, likely less experienced player, flags up and has their entire family go red. 

You can say "without consequence" but likely chances are, if ur guild was liked on the server chain then the bigger fish on it would be more than willing to help just because of the thirst for pvp content at the higher end of the game - and those guilds would then contest the server vs your opposition. It's a social game after all, despite how much a minority of people want to play it single player. 

tl;dr ur guild did some grief shit, got locked down for it, and had no one to help because again - you are likely griefers yourselves 

To Pearl Abyss

I understand your reasons for this kind of changes, but honestly I hope that two-sided wars never happen.

I'm ok with family karma, i don't think will affect the game of too many people.

I'm ok with marni realm recharge, tho i think the better aspect of BDO is the open world (i'm even against Magnus tbh) so why isolate even more player each-other? But, ok!

Black desert has an astonishing scenario and it's a waste use Magnus and lose the travelking experience. In this travel the risk to encounter enemies is part of our own personal adventure. It's pure adrenalina sometimes.

So why reduce BDO into a PvE game, when it's PvX side is it's streinght?! 

To encourage new players keep playing? They have season servers and Olvia, and nowadays, with the actual speed of gearing, they will be 630 after one season. Do they need more help? Really??

Some will answer me that there is Arsha if i want to PvP. But that's the point. I don't want to PvP at any cost. I want the freedom of having a world with no more boundaries and be surprised if someone attacks me suddently.

It is essencial (imho) that BDO remains a Sandbox Open world PvX game in which you can choose who you want to be and how to play.

Pls PA think about It!

Anyone who thinks this is a healthy or positive change for the game is still stuck in a seasonal server.

Good job PA, idc about that shitty pvp in this game anyways, good on you for the marni <3

That's just not what's happening at all. People don't use one sided decs to grief new players. The situation has already been described very clearly in the OP, if you aren't reading then don't comment.