Black Desert will begin in a moment.

Install the Black Desert Launcher if the game doesn't start.

Install the Black Desert Launcher to start the game.

The launcher will appear if it's installed.
If it doesn't, try to run your downloaded launcher.

Install Guide

1 Run BlackDesert_Installer_NAEU.exe to install the Black Desert launcher.

2 Start the game once installation is complete.

Forums

UTC 9 : 26 May 16, 2024
CEST 11 : 26 May 16, 2024
PDT 2 : 26 May 16, 2024
EDT 5 : 26 May 16, 2024
#Ranger #Maegu
Why does W + LMB cost Stamina for Ranger when it does not for Maegu?
Aug 9, 2023, 23:49 (UTC)
989 10
Last Edit : Aug 9, 2023, 23:55 (UTC)
# 1

I play both classes and noticed PA treats these two classes differently when it comes to W + LMB, that is ranged attack while moving forward.  Both have range attacks when in their normal attack stance (e.g., not in Awaken attack stance). 

Not sure if any other ranged class have similar discriminations, but it would be interesting to mention them if there is this type of discrimination.

However, stamina management has always been and still is a problem for the Ranger Class.  This was evident when PA had admitted recently to changing Stamina cost for certain Ranger Succession Skills.

I think its class discrimination and its not fair to the Ranger Class.  Please fix by not having W + LMB for the Ranger Class not cost her stamina.  I'd be fine with the change even if it were to mean the Ranger Class attack would be the same as Maegu for W + LMB.

Thanks

Last Edit : Aug 10, 2023, 00:30 (UTC)
# 2

Er... Blasting Gust is a very fast, short CD, nearly hit scan knockdown that can be used nearly on demand with no swapping really held in mind. Stamina is what balances Ranger from being off the walls OP, where as even with a non-stamina cost movement skill like W+LMB on Awakening Maegu, she is NOT op. Consider the whole kit when thinking about things like this.

Edit: I realize this post could be in reference to Succession Maegu, but the concept applies the same

11 142
Lv 65
Piag
Last Edit : Aug 10, 2023, 02:58 (UTC)
# 3
On: Aug 10, 2023, 00:29 (UTC), Written by Piag

Er... Blasting Gust is a very fast, short CD, nearly hit scan knockdown that can be used nearly on demand with no swapping really held in mind. Stamina is what balances Ranger from being off the walls OP, where as even with a non-stamina cost movement skill like W+LMB on Awakening Maegu, she is NOT op. Consider the whole kit when thinking about things like this.

Edit: I realize this post could be in reference to Succession Maegu, but the concept applies the same

It has to be rethought.  Now that PA has increased respawn rates for mobs all classes have to put out faster attacks or greater damage, but for the Ranger Class it means Stamina runs out a lot faster, and will not be able to keep up.

This is a problem not thought through, and they need to fix it.

Oh and forget about the Ranger Class using a Dehkia lamp.  Plain suicide.

Last Edit : Oct 28, 2023, 03:52 (UTC)
# 4

Maegu doesn't have a skill bound to w+lmb (outside of her completely useless basic attacks). Are you sure you're not getting something mixed up? Also consider that w+lmb on ranger actually triggers blasting gust (regular keybind is Q), w+lmb is just an alternate shortcut to use it forwards.

Last Edit : Oct 28, 2023, 04:49 (UTC)
# 5

this mf really out herre in yodieland complaining about w lmb brah its 2023

Last Edit : Oct 28, 2023, 09:46 (UTC)
# 6
On: Aug 9, 2023, 23:49 (UTC), Written by SpecteroftheGun

I play both classes and noticed PA treats these two classes differently when it comes to W + LMB, that is ranged attack while moving forward.  Both have range attacks when in their normal attack stance (e.g., not in Awaken attack stance). 

Not sure if any other ranged class have similar discriminations, but it would be interesting to mention them if there is this type of discrimination.

However, stamina management has always been and still is a problem for the Ranger Class.  This was evident when PA had admitted recently to changing Stamina cost for certain Ranger Succession Skills.

I think its class discrimination and its not fair to the Ranger Class.  Please fix by not having W + LMB for the Ranger Class not cost her stamina.  I'd be fine with the change even if it were to mean the Ranger Class attack would be the same as Maegu for W + LMB.

Thanks

Maegu succ doesn't have any skill on W+LMB ( since those are just basic attacks ) as Ranger thus no stamina consumption .....why is only Maegu though that you talk about, because all the other classes(except Archer since it also goes into a skill named "Winged Strike" which apparently does the damage but the crit is being nullified for those 5s CD) don't use stamina on W + LMB so they should just remove the activation of your Q ability from W+LMB and call it a day since then you'll not use stamina but you'll attack with BASIC attacks.

On: Aug 10, 2023, 02:40 (UTC), Written by SpecteroftheGun

Oh and forget about the Ranger Class using a Dehkia lamp.  Plain suicide.


 Except Woosa and Berserker every other class is a suicide class on Dehkia lamp especially in thornwood forest.

10 105
Lv Private
EeekAakEek
Last Edit : Oct 30, 2023, 22:37 (UTC)
# 7
On: Aug 10, 2023, 02:40 (UTC), Written by SpecteroftheGun

Oh and forget about the Ranger Class using a Dehkia lamp.  Plain suicide.

Gear or Skill issue. Get more DP or get better at your class, there's people doing dekhia ash forest on succ musa so clearly it's possible on ranger of all classes lmao

11 142
Lv 65
Piag
Last Edit : Nov 1, 2023, 00:09 (UTC)
# 8

Why doesn't maegu have ranger's range on every skill?

15 264
Lv Private
WONDERMAID
Last Edit : Dec 28, 2023, 21:06 (UTC)
# 9

why doent maegu have a grab? qq

Last Edit : Dec 28, 2023, 22:27 (UTC)
# 10
On: Oct 28, 2023, 04:49 (UTC), Written by Rainny

this mf really out herre in yodieland complaining about w lmb brah its 2023

I love readin thru threads and then you come to a post like this and bust out laughing.

But yea w lmb is the ultimate trash mob slayer for ranger, and the range is way longer than a normal attack. Did you spend most of your time running? I am at like breath 37 or something. Stam isn't that much of an issue haha.

Hey if they wanna give rangers more stam, I'm down. Gimme more chance to hop around and troll people.

Reply

Class Discussion

Discuss the classes of Black Desert here!

last
Search results will display posts in increments of 10,000.

We use cookies, with your consent, to customize content and advertising.
More information