TLDR:  PVE sucks no reason to play for that, PVP (you arent allowed to fight griefing jerks) so no reason to become a Hero, COMMUNITY is discouraged so no reason to stick around for that.    Utterly insane choice to remove organic pvp.

I've already stated that I think that PA should have made smaller changes - timers on one sided deccs with cooldowns.  YOu and others have failed to address why it's ok for guilds to use deccs to punish people whom they dislike or people whose post things that they don't like (versus defending rotations).  THOSE actions brought these changes.  I've yet to see any reason why THOSE bullying and harassing behaviors are ok by abusing the decc system.

True story.

PA made an instanced game with this f***ing Marni.

They could have used those new servers to instance the Node Wars which are lagging everytime but NOOOOOOOO, nonono! It's better to create an empty game instanced for solo play everywhere on the map!

You don't understand how works Arsha overall then.

I've grinded on Arsha.   We do understand

But the game has always been solo mode from the moment they went live for the first time.....

All I see now are the griefers that griefed before are still griefing now but you can't decc them anymore....and that's because one way deccs were a thing(and just because your guild-and I'm referring to whoever will come and say this- or alliance guilds didn't have this problem that doesnt mean it didn't exist) and it was abused the same way that bullying a low gs on a low grinding area just for entertainment was also a thing, the same way killing lifeskillers while gathering (sap, trees and whatever and only the lifeskiller was there) for entertainment. 

Family karma is better. Why? Because now you can't abuse being red and then change chars and be like nothing happened.

The guild decc thing is not good, yes, but how would you(and I'm referring to every one) have stopped the one guild wars? Maybe make it a 50b/week for one week of perma wars? And the declaration fees for one full day also should be made like 1b/day or 1b/6h (with a 2 day cooldown) of war with the guild that actually farms on the spot and griefs and not that guild that there's one person there or you don't like that guild and just decc them just because.

No, you don't.

Hmm... I think it would have been better, in addition to GVG both sided and instead of Marni's extension, to have a flag on rotation, meaning, like the lantern, and instead of Marni, you can flag on a rotation for 1 hour, same duration than Marni, so you can kill any griefer who comes along without karma loss. The player who comes along can kill him with the same rules that karma family wide etc, but not the one already farming there.

That way, griefers are not a problem anymore.

And it's doable by PA, since they did already Marni's on zones, Lanterns, etc...

I know you posted it without thinking just for troling, but...

Just flag up would be best if ti worked. But PA  didnt make the most simple thing to make PvP work - flag system. You want to PvP you flag, when someone comes to your spot see you flagged he attack you, he flags automaticaly and you have fun. If you are unflagged on spot, and someone come and want your spot should flag. Now of yo udont want to fight dont attack, he kills you and get red. Make reds to drop items. (I found it way better to downgrade, those hard obtained items is better to go to other person or market than to vanish)

Easy. Still there are ways to be abussed, but way way better than this griefing pradase.

Because if you go Arsha on hot spot you mainly will PvP not grind. There is no efitiency. The idea of normal servers is to grind and have some fun with PvP. The PvP has limits so not to become Arsha- nonstop fight. Conquest for spot is great if loser has something to lose. You fight winer takes the spot, loser go to search for other spot. That was the fun  of BDO the very reason many if not most people choose that game. To be honest since karmabombing exist that part was already destroying that fun. Now we gona two problems - more carmabombing and less players. Well actualy because of the second(marni) the firs might be less will see. But that will be the biggest problem - BDO should be MMO. And like MMO its failing hard lately. Also I must say that the new family karma is better for cleaning.

As for new players. yes they should be feeling better. And BDO makes their life way way easier. A new player can littary progress faster with months if not years. And PA if actualy wanted to makes things better could make Marni only for new players. But for many people the only logic explanation in their action is that they want to kill their own game...

BEcause history shows that that kinda changes dont lead to anything good. We wait and see.

I think something similar was proposed before. Maybe with new Feedback Board if its proposed in right way it will have chance. But then they refused simple increase in RBF rewards...

Anyway I found the idea good.