Black Desert will begin in a moment.

Install the Black Desert Launcher if the game doesn't start.

Install the Black Desert Launcher to start the game.

The launcher will appear if it's installed.
If it doesn't, try to run your downloaded launcher.

Install Guide

1 Run BlackDesert_Installer_NAEU.exe to install the Black Desert launcher.

2 Start the game once installation is complete.

Forums

UTC 17 : 47 May 15, 2024
CEST 19 : 47 May 15, 2024
PDT 10 : 47 May 15, 2024
EDT 13 : 47 May 15, 2024
#Suggestions
Add a grab to every class or PvP balance is impossible
Dec 22, 2023, 20:37 (UTC)
2498 270
1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 ... 29
Last Edit : Dec 26, 2023, 19:47 (UTC)
# 51
On: Dec 26, 2023, 17:08 (UTC), Written by BDO1fan


 Last I checked succ dk, mae, musa, absolutely shred people in milliseconds especially in Aos. You prepared to do baby damage in exchange for a grab cause you guys are not proposing ANY nerfs in exchange for grab. 

These high damage classes would need MAJOR damage reduction and to reduce protected ccs to one or two max. 

Say goodbye to  cc on wheel, or should they remove cc from airstrike? 

As far as the last time I checked, a lot of grab classes did just as much, some even more, damage than non-grab classes including DK. Therefore saying that a DK has damage to compensate for a lack of grab is dumb, let alone the fact that having high damage alone isn't as OP as being able to ignore SA/FG and that will be even more true after the next proposed balance patch the devs had revealed. Every class is going to need a grab after that.

Last Edit : Dec 26, 2023, 19:58 (UTC)
# 52
On: Dec 22, 2023, 20:37 (UTC), Written by Cleezus

With the upcoming change to PvP that are solely in favor of large scale PvP and a direct nerf to every non-grab/grapple class this is needed for balance. 

you cannot even remotely balance PvP going forward when certain classes have mechanics to directly bypass the upcoming nerf to small scale PvP. No matter what changes you make several classes will have an advantage and we are overdue for this simple solution. You can rebalance PvP after this.

for those that don't know on global labs they are adding protections across the board to skills which makes non grab classes suffer. 

The upcoming changes aren't even balanced because several classes are still getting more protections than others like warrior who can stay in super armor and have a grab.

I don't agree per se, but it's interesting that you can't resist a grab where as you can resist everything else. The answer might be more in that?

Last Edit : Dec 26, 2023, 20:28 (UTC)
# 53
On: Dec 26, 2023, 19:47 (UTC), Written by A72391

As far as the last time I checked, a lot of grab classes did just as much, some even more, damage than non-grab classes including DK. Therefore saying that a DK has damage to compensate for a lack of grab is dumb, let alone the fact that having high damage alone isn't as OP as being able to ignore SA/FG and that will be even more true after the next proposed balance patch the devs had revealed. Every class is going to need a grab after that.

Based take, thank you. Never understood this "dk does so much damage", ok? Everyone does damage, there is so much damage in the game at the moment. At least other classes are tanky enough to not get obliterated.

Lv Private
Delete
Last Edit : Dec 26, 2023, 20:45 (UTC)
# 54
On: Dec 26, 2023, 19:42 (UTC), Written by A72391

Once again, all you can do is missquote others and selectively cherrypick what thye said. I won't even bother to quote here what the person you are quoting says about grabs, because that would be too easy. The rest of your post is more of you just arguing about arguing rather than offering different perspectives on the matter.

If you want to quote PeaceInChaos and try to prove he pointed grab as the only problem, be my guest. Do it, don't be shy.

XD

Next, I'm precisely telling you the other perspectives, when you're focused on grabs. 

On: Dec 26, 2023, 19:42 (UTC), Written by A72391

One thing I have to say is, I have never seen a segment of players defend a skill so desperately like some grab players (you) defend their beloved grab skill. You want to talk about removing iframe? take it, I do not need it, don't give me any compensation either! You on the other hand are hanging to dear life, defending your prescious grab;

On the topic in which you're focusing solely on grabs, players are defending grabs. 

Oooh my, what a surprise. But another excellent example of your narrow-minded point of view, you can't even view the discussion YOU triggered. 

Now, saying that a sorcerer don't need Iframes... Stop using them and we'll see! XD If you had included Iframes in your proposal, we wouldn't be arguing here. But you didn't. 

You're trying arguments out of bad faith, it's disturbing :

-if grab is not a problem, why not give it to every class 

-why are you defending grabs so desperately (well, you're only attacking grabs, right?) 

Personally, I wouldn't ask for the removal of Iframes. It's powerful, but it's only a tool, like grabs.

In case you didn't realize, people are complaining as much against Iframes of your class than against grabs, but at some point a nihilistic behavior brings nothing good. What we need is a better balance, not a simplistic removal of one tool. 

On: Dec 26, 2023, 19:42 (UTC), Written by A72391

unfortunately, you don't have the facts nor the ability to present your case in a convincing manner nor have one to begin with as I have show repeatedly, dismantling your case piece by piece. If this was in court, your case would be thrown out after I was done with your first post. :)

How cute. Close to Ad Personam, now. 

https://www.naeu.playblackdesert.com/en-US/Forum/ForumTopic/Detail?_topicNo=24952&_page=1 

Read again. You simply repeated what you said last time, and it was already a fiasco for you back then. The case is already closed since last year, in fact. XD

Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 01:15 (UTC)
# 55

@Sadalsuud Your desperation is evident as you try to seek opinions of others that aren't even backingup your case for Grab the way u think they are. Quote them yourself if you don't believe me. In the meantime, I'll be waiting for you to contradict any of my points against grabs needing to even exist. Your attempts at decepcion may work to delude yourself but the GM's and devs following the conversation I am sure have no problem understanding, and u deep inside know as well as me you have left all of my points standing because you are incapable of countering them. You keep constructing strawmen, I'll keep exposing them, let the devs be the judges. :)

Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 01:20 (UTC)
# 56

Ok I want to introduce another angle for this discussion.

27 classes in this game. 

Lets hear your argument for why these classes don't have grabs but others do.

Witch, no grab despite its male counterpart wizard having grab?

Dark Knight / Sorc, have iframes, but Tamer has actually got more iframes than dk and yet has a grab?

Archer / Maegu, they are ranged so don't deserve grab right, but wait, awak corsair is ranged and has ranged grab?

Musa / Maewha, they are too mobile grab would be op, but doesn't lahn have the fastest grab engage, can't ninja stealth engage you into grab?

Woosa, idk equate that to wizard/sage or something use your imagination.

Shai is in a unique spot but at this point, can't leave anyone behind.

The point is, the reasons you don't want the last 9 classes to have grabs, should apply to at least 1 other class that does have a grab.

If you're going to exlude classes from having grabs, you should apply the ruling to all classes equally.

Has Grab (18) Does Not Have Grab (9)

Warrior

Hashashin

Sage

Ranger

Guardian

Drakania

Nova

Corsair

Lahn

Berserker

Tamer

Striker

Mystic

Valkyrie

Kunoichi

Ninja

Wizard

Scholar

Sorceress

Maegu

Shai

Musa

Maewha

Dark Knight

Archer

Woosa

Witch

Lv Private
Delete
Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 04:54 (UTC)
# 57

Can yall go to sleep? J doesnt read forums nor devs anyways

Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 06:34 (UTC)
# 58
On: Dec 26, 2023, 12:10 (UTC), Written by A72391

lol so all I have to do then is to reroll to sage and then just keep on saying the same thing about grab being game-breaking? Or do I forcibly have to become a Berserker? It's too funny how the entire argument of the pro-grablets resides entirely on sorc-hood. Such a vulnerable stance you choose to base your entire argument on and very easy to topple!

So this is what I'll do, I'll change my main to Berserker, come back here. Say the same thing I've been saying regarding reality, that grabs are a win button and that they have no counter and counter everything and should be erradicated or given to everyone; and you won't have a single argument against me and you'll be completely disarmed, because I will be a Berserker class... good job! Logic is so beautiful ^.^

Actually I really think u will be suck at playing any class without iframe/gaps. Average sorc main complains about grab. 

19 166
Lv 66
CCaJJ
Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 08:34 (UTC)
# 59
On: Dec 27, 2023, 06:34 (UTC), Written by CCaJJ

Actually I really think u will be suck at playing any class without iframe/gaps. Average sorc main complains about grab. 

Its not really about sorcs.

Last Edit : Dec 27, 2023, 11:57 (UTC)
# 60
On: Dec 27, 2023, 01:20 (UTC), Written by Ascenn

Ok I want to introduce another angle for this discussion.

27 classes in this game. 

Lets hear your argument for why these classes don't have grabs but others do.

Witch, no grab despite its male counterpart wizard having grab?

Dark Knight / Sorc, have iframes, but Tamer has actually got more iframes than dk and yet has a grab?

Archer / Maegu, they are ranged so don't deserve grab right, but wait, awak corsair is ranged and has ranged grab?

Musa / Maewha, they are too mobile grab would be op, but doesn't lahn have the fastest grab engage, can't ninja stealth engage you into grab?

Woosa, idk equate that to wizard/sage or something use your imagination.

Shai is in a unique spot but at this point, can't leave anyone behind.

The point is, the reasons you don't want the last 9 classes to have grabs, should apply to at least 1 other class that does have a grab.

If you're going to exlude classes from having grabs, you should apply the ruling to all classes equally.

Has Grab (18) Does Not Have Grab (9)

Warrior

Hashashin

Sage

Ranger

Guardian

Drakania

Nova

Corsair

Lahn

Berserker

Tamer

Striker

Mystic

Valkyrie

Kunoichi

Ninja

Wizard

Scholar

Sorceress

Maegu

Shai

Musa

Maewha

Dark Knight

Archer

Woosa

Witch

On top of this i'd like to say that Berserker is faster, more protected, more heals, more tankiness, consumes less stamina ( 0 ) than musa and has multiple grabs lol

15 264
Lv Private
WONDERMAID
1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 ... 29
Reply

Feedback

Share your feedback and suggestions to help us develop Black Desert.

last
Search results will display posts in increments of 10,000.

We use cookies, with your consent, to customize content and advertising.
More information