Family Name: SeedofYggdrasil

Region(NA/EU): EU

Comments/Suggestions : I've been dedicated to lifeskilling since I first started playing in 2018, and it has always been my favorite aspect of the game. Over the years, however, lifeskilling has been neglected in favor of other content. While recently PA attempted to revisit Trading, it turned out to be a disaster due to largely ignoring player feedback and the developers being out of touch with what made lifeskilling enjoyable. In the end the Trading rework was abandoned and removed from the game.

This post aims to provide a general list of Ideas for PA regarding what dedicated lifeskillers and the community want to see for lifeskilling in the future.

General:

- Suggestion to family-wide Lifeskills [Forum post link]

- Show Lifeskill spots on the worldmap [Forum post link]

- Improve CP usage of older content [Forum post link]

- Introduce an Intergrated daily/weekly quest UI [Forum post link]

- Expand LoML into a Lifeskiller Paradise [Forum post link]

- Intorduce Season of Life [Forum post link]

- Add rewards to level past G50 100% [Forum post link]

- Rework the Progression Pass [Forum post link]

- Introduce failstacks to Lifeskill gear

- Lift all tag restrictions for lifeskillers (Idea: make when you tag your character "Item copy" mandotary and tagging itself is optional. If you only do Item copy, the lift all restirctions ?)

Gathering:

- Make Tanning relevant (Idea: add Leather/Feather crates and let Mystical Feather drop frequently from tanning ?)

- "Green Artisan" mini-game should proc 100% of the time when gathering rare materials [Forum post link]

- Adjust stats of animals [Forum post link]

- Energy consumption for gathering is too high [Forum post link]

- Make Gathering more Agris efficient [Forum post link]

- Add more gathering spots to LoML

Fishing:

- Bring back active fishing [Forum post link]

- Harpoon Fishing Revamp [Forum post link]

- Make Harpooning minigame easier and accessible from all ship types [Forum post link]

- Lock the camera during harpooning minigame [Forum post link]

- Fish Guide changes [Forum post link]

Hunting:

- Make all classes equally good for Hunting [Forum post link]

- Fix Matchlock desync shots [Forum post link]

- Rework older Hunting spots 

- Simplifying Breath items

Cooking:

- Buff Imperial Cooking [Forum post link]

- Add a "Buy to storage" function to vendors [Forum post link]

- Indroduce a Mastery tool "Manos: Chef Spoon"

Alchemy:

- How to reintroduce Imperial Alchemy [Forum post link]

- Indroduce a Mastery tool "Manos: Catalyzer tube"

Processing:

- Bring back AFK processing (Idea: maybe add lightstone set: -1000 Processing Mastery and +10k LT, but your character gets the overweight slowdown when equiped ?)

- Add processing byproducts [Forum post link]

- Add search and sort to Processing [QoL] [Forum post link]

Training:

- Mythical Arduanatt still falling out of sky randomly [Forum post link]

- Alternate T10 Forms for Dine and Doom [Forum post link]

- Remove Water Stamina from T10 Unicorn Completely [Forum post link]

- The PEN Training rework/ballance and content recycling [Forum post link]

- Rework or remove mount skill exp

- More Horse Racing modes: Allow us to use T8s instead of race Horses

Trading:

- Bring back Trading (Idea: Either copy paste bartering or BDMobile system of active trading, so PA can't screw up again ?)

- Additional Trade Crates [Forum post link]

- Introduce Trading quests [Forum post link]

Farming:

- Farming Rework [Forum post link]

- New forms of farming [Forum post link]

- Add farming mastery [Forum post link]

- Make Seeds stack [Forum post link]

Sailing:

- Better Loot Inticators for Sea Content [Forum post link]

- A few Sailing QoL Suggestions [Forum post link]

- Improve sailors: management, sets, leveling [Forum post link]

- Sailor Slots should use CP like workers do [Forum post link]

- Ship Cannon Improvements [Forum post link]

- New boat suggestion: Cargo Ship [Forum post link]

-The (not so) great expedition: make sailing Margoria and SMH great (again?) [Forum post link]

- SMH should drop more Claws of the Waves [Forum post link]

- Monster Zone Info screen for sea spots [Forum post link]

Barter:

- Buff bartering [Forum post link]

- Reduce weight of Barter items [Forum post link]

- Remove weight from sailors [Forum post link]

- Allow us to interact with the wharf manager on our boat [Forum post link]

Others:

- Make Rich Merchant's Ring obtainable through lifeskilling 

- Garmoth crystal slots for Lifeskill character [Forum post link]

- Add more fame brackets with rewards [Forum post link]

- Buff Khan Heart and Lifeskill Alchemy Stones [Forum post link]

- Add more ways to make glue [Forum post link]

- Progress bars for titles [Forum post link]

- Server Wide Lifeskill Buffs [Forum post link]

- Buffs: Furniture, Church for lifeskills and combine scrolls 

Quality of Life:

- Improve Energy pot exchange [Forum post link]

- Moss-Covered Map exchange [Forum post link]

- Miraculous Fish Tank - add sorting [Forum post link]

- Lamp for Forest Path Wagon [Forum post link]

- Remove the RNG when hiring sailors [Forum post link]

Bugs:

- Fix Lopter spawns and drops [Forum post link]

- Large Goldmont Battleships mixed up [Forum post link]

Note: This thread is a work in progress. If you feel like I missed or want to add something, please comment below, and I will try to add it to the post (please add a link to the related post).

Thank you for all this hard work you are putting into advocating for lifeskillers. It is much appreciated and I agree with all of your suggestions! All I do anymore is lifeskill and I love it, hope they make it better not worse.

Feel free to add any of mine

Hunting:

[Feedback] Remove khalks and blue whales from hunting leap quests | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

Fishing:

[Feedback] Fish Guide changes | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Remove green fish from harpoon fish tables | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Active fishing only - Fishing nets | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Miraculous Fish Tank - add sorting | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Lock the camera during harpooning minigame | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

Trading:

[Feedback] New boat suggestion: Cargo Ship | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Lamp for Forest Path Wagon | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

Sailing:

[Feedback] Unable to brand Ebenruth's Nol ??? | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Change the way we hire sailors | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] New sea monster titles not retroactive??? | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Rework Sea Monster Habitat (Lekreshan area) to be more like Saltwater Crocodile area | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Recipe for Ravinia's Moss Remover | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Remove weight from sailors | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Enhance Rickun's Shipwrecked Boat | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Monster Zone Info screen for lower-end and sea spots? | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Moss-Covered Map exchange | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Large Goldmont Battleships mixed up | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Fix Lopter spawns and drops | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

[Feedback] Claws of the Waves - Crow Coin solution | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

General:

[Feedback] Progress bars for titles | Black Desert NA/EU (playblackdesert.com)

It would be nice if packing imperial boxes could give processing exp, even if it's a tiny amount.  Sure, it's 100% success, it still takes time.

Thanks for listing your ideas. I've added most of them that fit in there well.

I want to also add: Rework Sea Monster Habitat (Lekreshan area) to be more like Saltwater Crocodile area

but it's not really coherent enough. Maybe make a combination of your Idea and the second comment 

Good job! 😎

I see people not agreeing with something..

If you don't agree with a suggestion, at least you say why and argue about it... clicking on (don't agree) just if you don't agree is easy without any feedback. We are all here to discuss ideas and all of them are welcome!